WITH MALICE TOWARD NONE, WITH CHARITY TOWARD ALL. Perhaps some day, but we still have not settled what sort of intellectual culture we are going to have just yet. James Lileks has little patience for another "discovery from the 9/10 fossil bed, another attempt to insist that nothing changed - the old paradigms, the old arguments, the old hyperboles hanging on the cars of the long postmodern circus train are more relevant now than ever." Noemie Emery sees the usual carping from the usual carpers, and despairs. Joshua Chafetz identifies yet more things not in your name, and earns an endorsement from Daniel Drezner. And so the beat goes on.