Bet on emergence. "If jazz were a society, it would be a liberal one." From the same essay, trade unites. "Commerce may make people less parochial, but this is hardly the same thing as
destroying local communities. In fact, commerce seems to undermine the worst tendencies of localism: exchange across communities and borders
leads to more cooperation, tolerance, and peace with a wider array of people."
Well, yes.
What constitutes a fulfilling life? "While the US and Europe share a broad commitment to classical Liberalism, and Democracy, we have very different definitions of the Public Good, which means different views of what we want out of life, and what we consider fulfilling. In broad and simplistic terms, the US emphasizes material wealth, opportunity, and individual liberty while Europe values community health, a shared common good, and a sense of place. From the European perspective the US has a cult of the individual, and that's why it has too many guns, obscenely large cars, can't build a public transportation system, and has dysfunctional public spaces. From the US perspective Europeans are unmotivated unproductive slackers who would rather sip coffee all day than work, and their idea of a shared common good means stealing from the successful to give to the losers."

When "
your truth" is
a lie. "You cannot have identity politics on the Left, valorizing non-white people and granting them special, race-based privileges, without calling up demons on the right. They either didn’t see it – perhaps thinking that all white people were like the milquetoast liberals they knew from campuses and newsrooms – or they were so drunk on the thrill of transgression that they didn’t care. Well, now that demon is here, and it is not the fault of conservatives who warned them."
The
rigged glass bead game. "It’s an open secret that the pressure to produce a constant flood of papers that are publishable and, better yet, interesting enough to spark headlines leads to corner-cutting, 'data torture' and overclaiming — or, sometimes, outright fraud. The result is an expensive self-licking ice cream cone of grant applications and publications, but the actual contribution to human knowledge is often lacking."
The weekly round-up of mostly pithy elaborations on traditional Cold Spring Shops themes follows.