That economic elites feel especially threatened by political dissent has been clear at least since the publication of the Trilateral Commission's Crisis of Democracy report in 1975. These elites are concerned about declining rates of real growth which exacerbate social tensions, about lower corporate profits, and about the failure of the military budget to keep pace with increases in Gross National Product. They are eager to get corporate capitalism moving again. To this end, they would like to keep workers' wages down, cut spending for social programs, and open the military spigot more widely. Fearing the kind of grass-roots resistance to elite aims that characterized the 1960s, the Trilateral leaders argue for "a moderation of democracy" in the interests of "governability."These days, the bĂȘte noire might be the Davos set or the World Economic Forum, and the dissenters might be right-populist as well as elements of the traditional left: and the "moderation of democracy" now becomes "countering disinformation in the name of democracy."
The reaction of the ruling class, though, is the same.
The effect of the secrecy mystique -- the notion that there are vital decisions which only a select few can and must make -- is to keep out of the public domain information that is indispensable to the formation of public policy.If the physics of a fission-fusion-fission weapon is something you can get along without knowing about, dear reader, might you think differently about the past two years and counting of corona tyranny, including the suppression of dissenting scientific points of view?
To the credit of The Progressive, contributors continue to endorse the exchange of ideas.
We all expressed concern to live in a time when lies are common currency and truth has been devalued. We said this underscores the importance of fact-based journalism and honest investigation into official pronouncements.You give neither a Carter administration nor a Trump administration the power to enforce prior restraints.
I ventured that, with regard to President Donald Trump’s refusal to accept the results of the Nov. 3 election, the U.S. press has been doing a fairly good job. The president’s allegations of widespread electoral fraud are being appropriately tagged as “baseless,” “without evidence” and “unfounded and erroneous.”
The visitors I’ve met — from Latin America, Asia, Europe and Africa — often express amazement at how much freedom the U.S. press enjoys. Some marvel at the ability of journalists here to criticize and even ridicule those in power. Most dryly observe that they could not undercut government officials without putting themselves at risk.That assertion is in part a rebuke of the social-media-legacy-journalism-administrative-state nexus that would suppress "disinformation" in the name of "Our Democracy." Good. That article concludes "Our obligation as journalists and opinion leaders is to insist that truth is knowable, and deserves more fidelity than falsehoods." Also good, as that is a rebuke to the kind of truth-is-socially-constructed-and-voices-must-be-equitably-heard idiocy that has destroyed the academy.
But sadly, I told the visitors, the ability of U.S. journalists to tell the truth has been substantially diminished by the widespread erosion of regard for truth itself. Large numbers of Americans believe, based on zero evidence, that Democrats, the media and the “deep state” stole the election from Trump, at the same time as they believe that COVID-19, which has killed a quarter of a million Americans, is a hoax.
My message to the visitors was that we face a common enemy: the preponderance of lies. We also share a common goal: to make truth matter.
Long ago, in the early days of the independent blogosphere, the organizing principle was that a distributed network of people, each with different areas of expertise, could more effectively fact-check the elites than the elites, whether organized into countervailing collectivities or not, could do. That "independent fact checker" has become a joke expression for "paid narrative enforcer" does not vitiate the power of emergence. Two passages toward the end of that essay reinforce the point. First, "To the elites, 'disinformation' is simply information that the establishment in media and government find inconvenient (or embarrassing)." Second, "Thanks to the open internet, we’ve been able to expose the regime media and hold it accountable for its own words and actions. Our student-driven, viral reporting is exactly what the elites want to put a stop to, and that’s why we all need to keep fighting." Or keeping our independent web journals going, or occasionally tagging regime tweets as misinformation or otherwise demonstrating the folly of the gate-keepers' methods.As an end-note, that May issue also includes a letter from Gerald Piel, who then published Scientific American, that concluded,
If a hydrogen bomb turns up in the hands of Idi Amin or some terrorist gang, it will not be made from a recipe published in a magazine. Very likely, it will be one of our own bombs, deployed within their reach by a blundering decision made in secret.That's right, a sideshow in the argument over prior restraint was whether a nest of pacifists in Madison was going to release information that would enable a third world Big Man to build a thermonuclear device. A dozen years later, just before the Soviet Union ceased to be, Tom Clancy published The Sum of All Fears. and the terrorist nuke was built from ... an Israeli broken arrow that used Savannah River plutonium the Mossad somehow purloined. In the novel there is a hypothetical passage from an astrophysical journal, "Imagine the center of a star with an X-ray flux of [some very big number.]" You still have to somehow procure the materials and machine them.
Our best protection against Guardians of Approved Thought, no matter what their proclivities might be, is to Think for Ourselves.

No comments:
Post a Comment