17.11.26

IF YOU THINK INFORMATION IS COSTLY, TRY IGNORANCE.

Today's prize for saying dumb things goes to Our President, who claims to have an economics degree and should know better.  During last February's Speech from the Throne, he offered the following.
"Tonight, I'm pleased to announce that I have negotiated the new ratepayer protection pledge," the president said. "We're telling the major tech companies that they have the obligation to provide for their own power needs. They can build their own power plants as part of their factory so that no one's prices will go up. And in many cases, prices of electricity will go down for the community, and very substantially down."

While it's hard to know if prices will, in fact, go down because of these agreements, the plan realizes that the largest impediment to rapid AI growth is public opinion. If the industry can grow without straining the grid and its ratepayers, AI will prosper.
Our President is of the opinion that the data centers can operate independently of the common carrier power grid.  That thinking bothers me.  "None of that matters here, where a data center, which is to say an air conditioned building full of servers and other electronics is a noxious facility just like any abattoir or steel works."  Unlike the steel works, though, the data center is a reliable consumer of base-load capacity, a point a Sierra Club type at Common Dreams fails to understand.  "A Massive Buildout of Data Centers Powered by Gas Is the Opposite of Affordability."  She's laboring under the delusion that a 24-hour operation can be effectively kept humming by windmills and solar panels.
When a utility company decides to build a new gas power plant, the money it takes to build and maintain it does not come from the utility’s CEO or the Big Tech companies who want more electricity; we pay for the gas power plant in our utility bills every month. The cost of building and maintaining gas power plants has significantly and persistently increased in the US, contributing to increased prices for customers across the country. In contrast, the cost of renewables continues to fall.

When our utility companies fail to build enough low-cost clean electricity and instead increase their reliance on expensive fossil fuel power plants—as many are doing in response to data center demand—prices rise.
A few weeks ago, Our President attempted to spare rate-payers from paying for construction work in progress undertaken by investor-owned electric utilities by issuing a ukase.  "New and large, in some cases gigantic, Data Centers are mandated by me to make their own electricity, and give or sell any excess back to the local community, or grid. If companies want to make their Data Centers popular, pay the community, and/or individuals within the community, a 'dividend.' I have watched the process closely, and Data Centers that were highly unpopular in a certain area have become extremely popular when a financial deal is struck."

In principle, that might work out.  And pigs might fly.
The costs associated with new data centers—which can bring thousands of jobs and millions of dollars in revenue to nearby communities—could be better kept under control simply by making it easier for power companies to meet demand.

That's the approach that lawmakers in Ohio and New Hampshire have taken. Each state has implemented a policy framework called "consumer-regulated energy" (CRE) to allow the owners of data centers (and other major industrial facilities) to buy their power from third-party providers instead of the centralized grid.

Not only does that keep any given facility's energy needs isolated from the rest of the grid—which, according to a Cato Institute report, means that big data centers can be built and powered at "zero cost to taxpayers and ratepayers"—it also speeds up their construction tremendously. When data centers can source their power from a third party, they bypass much of the decade's worth of infrastructure buildout that's necessary to connect to the grid.

A CRE-adjacent framework could soon be implemented nationwide. Earlier this year, Sen. Tom Cotton (R–Ark.) introduced the DATA Act, which would exempt off-grid data centers from federal regulations, making the entire process faster and cheaper.

If data center construction is increasing electricity bills, the best solution isn't a knee-jerk ban on the industry. It's common-sense reforms that make it possible for everyone, and every data center, to get the power they need.
On the one hand, a data center might want sufficient power to stay in operation when there's a hiccup in the grid.  On the other, the cost to the data center to secure its own power source, while it avoids burdening electricity rate-payers and taxpayers, might burden the consumers of internet and telecommunication services (and students cheating on term papers?) with higher rates for connectivity.  Nor will the outcome please the Sierra Club types.
Data center developers and utilities can stop this onslaught of plans for new gas power plants and rely on affordable, available clean energy options instead. With proper planning, both data center developers and utilities can be part of the solution. In the meantime, we’ll continue to track utilities’ plans for new gas power plants, and you can join us to push utilities and data center developers to make better, cheaper, healthier decisions.
While Our President dictates and the environmentalists demand, the builders of data centers do a little recycling of their own.  "Data centers are turning to old jet engines as the wait for power grows."  Don't you love unintended consequences?
Stuck in years-long lines for grid connections and new turbines, some AI data centers are making their own electricity with converted jet engines, the New York Times reported Tuesday.

The engines, pulled from retired aircraft and rebuilt to burn natural gas, aren’t anyone’s idea of a permanent power plant. But they’re another sign of how far power supply has fallen behind the AI buildout.

For companies stuck in those lines, the main draw of converted jet engines is how quickly the engines can be up and running. “It’s all about getting power as fast as possible,” Rystad Energy analyst Audun Martinsen told the Times. With jet-powered units, “they can have a data center running in 24 months,” he said.

Hooking up 100 megawatts to the grid in Northern Virginia, by comparison, takes about seven years, according to the International Energy Agency. Most power capacity is expected to come on by 2031, an executive at Mitsubishi Power, one of the world’s top makers of power generation equipment, told Bloomberg last week.
I suspect a repurposed jet engine spinning an alternator is more polluting and has less Third Law efficiency than a purpose-built peaking station.  Those builders, however, have full order books already.
AI data-center developers are hunting for used gas turbines and retired jet engines because ordering brand-new power equipment could leave their servers waiting for electricity until the next decade.

Some companies are buying refurbished machines, while others are converting aircraft-engine technology into generators that can run alongside their computing facilities.
That vertical integration, however, might come at the expense of benefits to general rate-payers connected to the grid.
Electricity is a capital-heavy business. Most of what consumers pay for isn't the power itself, but the infrastructure that produces and delivers it: generation, transmission, substations, and distribution. Once that infrastructure exists, the marginal cost of serving additional load is relatively low. What makes electricity expensive isn't use. It's underuse.

For this reason, steady demand has historically driven prices down, not up. When more electricity flows across the same wires, fixed costs are spread over more kilowatt-hours. Utilities recover investments more efficiently, and per-unit costs fall.
The joker in the deck?  A data center bubble.  Those converted jet engines are not stranded assets in a regulated utility rate base.  Interesting times.

2 comments:

David Foster said...

"When a utility company decides to build a new gas power plant, the money it takes to build and maintain it does not come from the utility’s CEO or the Big Tech companies who want more electricity".....I'm pretty sure that large industrial users of electricity do in fact get capital cost allocated to there bills, just as residential users do. The initial construction is likely debt-financed

Stephen Karlson said...

David, there aren't enough hours in the day to rivet-count a Sierra Club post, or any Common Dreams stuff for that matter. There are all sorts of screwy things involved in regulated utilities, including putting construction work in the rate base before the unit comes on line, and compensating owners for stranded assets. That's Lynne Kiesling stuff.

The data centers affect the regulatory hearings in two ways: rate payers on the hook for that construction, expenses for which are allocated to all consumers, even if the construction is explicitly in support of a steel mill or data center, and feared expenses for stranded assets, should the data centers be a bubble or a steel mill not get built.