But in the course of following her links, and linked supporting arguments, I got to "Mapping the Neo-Manosphere(s): New Directions for Research," a Minimal Publishable Unit in a Sage publication. Enjoy the abstract.
In a digital ecology that is increasingly conducive to social harms, misogynist ideology operates across a spectrum of primarily online actors known colloquially as ‘the Manosphere’. The manosphere and its associated red pill philosophy has now been around, in its current transnational and highly networked form, for over a decade. Yet the manosphere, particularly in the context of Covid-19, influencer culture and the affordances of new social media sites, has evolved rapidly in this time, and scholarship has yet to adequately capture these developments. This paper begins with a stocktake of contemporary literature on the manosphere and its core themes, before evaluating the evolving status of this online ecosystem of anti-women actors. It advances our theoretical comprehension of the neo-manosphere and its likely future directions by identifying and evaluating the four key developments which distinguish it from the earlier manosphere; namely migrations to new platforms, mainstreaming and monetization, ideological and ethnic diversification, and overlap with other extreme ideologies, most of which are driven by recommender algorithms.Silly me, thinking research had to extend a conversation. "I was never clever enough to make up my own research practices, in which an extended literature review could constitute an entire article, without any testable propositions or data collection. My view of such research? "A 'narrative based article with evidence-based commentary' is a fancy way of saying it's an extended literature review with no data collection." The authors of "Mapping" lean into that.
We draw on approximately 100 recent scholarly publications as well as materials produced by members of the contemporary manosphere that are relevant to our analysis. The article concludes by considering emerging literature on educational interventions and disengagement from the manosphere. In addition to new mappings, which reflect both political shifts and the ever-changing nature of digital networks, we are also interested in new theorisations of the male supremacist ecosystem.Yes, dear reader, and they did get a Minimal Publishable Unit out of it, despite no attempt to lay out currents of disagreement that might provide an opportunity for additional scholarship.
There used to be this convention in scholarly papers of something grandiloquently called the "literature review" that serves the useful function of structuring an argument. So-and-so argues this, and I have evidence that calls that into question. But I'm not corroborating this other scholar, who called it into question in a different way.The Australian Research Council paid for this work, which, in the way of critical studies, concludes with potted political economy.
As we move into the era of Web 3.0, a new set of technological affordances, underpinned by virtual reality, automation and artificial intelligence will create new possibilities for male supremacists to sabotage, shame, and indoctrinate (Frances-Wright and Ayad 2024; Ging 2023). Already, deep fake technologies enable malicious actors to create images that violate dignity for example through juxtaposing high-profile women’s faces onto pornographic images (O’Farrell 2023). Such technologies are also being mobilised by anti-feminists to ‘fix’ images of perceived ‘broken’ people, as in the recent 4chan-led campaign, ‘DignifAI,’ designed to dress ‘degenerate’ women more modestly using AI software (Dickson 2024). In both cases, women are humiliated; their bodily autonomy and agency removed. The future implications of AI are not yet known but the ongoing failure to regulate technology companies indicates that the manosphere will continue to optimise technology in order to amplify its messages. Meanwhile, the continued dominance of neoliberal forms of government emphasising free market ideologies opposed to regulation of the marketplace will elicit increasingly individualist forms of response and resilience. While the tactical femininities and masculinities offered by the manosphere may offer its followers short-term, individual ‘solutions’, these are patriarchal forms of dignity (Kandiyoti 1988) and they work in the service of larger reactionary projects invested in rolling back human rights and facilitating human exploitation at global scale.Where is the Australian William Proxmire to confer a Golden Wombat on this?

No comments:
Post a Comment