Here's one manifestation of the miracle, from the house organ for all wokeness, all the time, in higher education.
Democrats repeatedly pledged to lower living costs for Americans.Nice try. Pell grants subsidize consumption, and they do as much to make college affordable as those insurance subsidies on the Obama Care exchanges, which is to say, nothing. "Need-based aid" is a fancier way of subsidizing consumption. That's business as usual for Democrats. "There has never been a single clue that Democrats ever gave a damn about 'affordability,' unless you mean bribing welfare dependents and government check-collectors with 'free' money." But as Donald Boudreaux quips, "In doing economic policy analysis, economists too readily assume that miracles regularly occur." His article offers numerous other occurrences of wishful thinking, generally involving second-order implications. The ineffectiveness of consumption subsidies is straightforward.
When it comes to college costs, that affordability agenda must first focus on closing a projected $17 billion shortfall in Pell grant funding before lawmakers tackle more ambitious policy ideas such as doubling the maximum need-based aid to $15,000, higher education experts said this week.
“You want to make sure that students can continue to get Pell before you’re trying to expand it,” said Alex Holt, a moderate right-leaning higher education policy expert. “It’s not necessarily giving students more money in their pocket. So, I can understand why that’s hard as a legislator from an affordability perspective. But ultimately you do need to save Pell. That’s an affordability issue.”
Protecting Pell is just one of several concrete steps that Democrats need to take in order to protect their new majorities and win the White House in 2028, Holt and others said. With that power, Democrats could then take bigger and bolder swings on higher ed policy.
But the wishful thinking of court intellectuals who might be able to engage in rent-seeking at taxpayer expense, never mind whether any students benefit by it, is standard issue mid-twenty-first-century wishful thinking. If you seek unconventional wishful thinking, check out "US midterm elections anticipate explosive growth of the class struggle" as offered by the heirs to Leon Trotsky. The essay opens predictably.
Behind Tuesday’s midterm elections, which produced the largest defeat of a sitting president’s party in half a century, lies an immense growth of social anger over the cost of living, war, social inequality and the assault on democratic rights. That anger cannot and will not be contained within electoral forms. It will erupt in the form of the class struggle.That's fairly standard socialist rhetoric, as is the recognition that rent seeking exists. The miracle comes toward the end of the piece.
Equality and an end to the domination of society by the oligarchy cannot be won under capitalism. The [Democratic Socialists] speaks for privileged sections of the upper middle class, which seek not to end the wealth of the oligarchy but a more favorable distribution of it within the top 10 percent of the population. Genuine socialism means the transfer of power to the working class, the expropriation of the ill-gotten wealth of the oligarchy, and the placing of the banks and giant corporations under the democratic control of the working class.It's been what, 85 years since Joe Stalin took out a contract on Leon Trotsky, and the vanguardism goes on as if it's still 1941. Multiple miracles are required: the organizing, the creation of the vanguard, the selling of real socialism (before or after Trotsky joined Lenin?) all before that death knell of capitalist private property sounds and the expropriators are expropriated. And Marxists call religion an opiate?
The decisive question is leadership. The radicalization expressed in the vote will not develop spontaneously into a conscious movement for socialism. That requires bringing this perspective into every struggle: exposing the role of the Democrats, the DSA and the trade union apparatus, building rank-and-file committees, and winning the most advanced workers and young people to socialism. That is the task of the Socialist Equality Party.


No comments:
Post a Comment