That's the church my parents worshipped at for many years, although they stopped attending when the minister at the time stepped down. The minister was subsequently called to a Unitarian congregation on the east side of Milwaukee. Go figure. Many years ago my mom observed that the church had "failed" her kids, in that none of us stuck with it in any way. It didn't bother me any that they stopped going, for instance.
It might be that the church, as run, failed the children of other members as well. On occasion I'd dip into their social media more out of curiosity than nostalgia, and along with the bulletins and announcements (the order of worship would not be out of place at York Minster) were a lot of references to their inclusive and welcoming community. It's jarring to see that language at the Starbucks drive-through: in the church setting, it means "We do not view alternative lifestyles as mortal sins." So it is in the world of Baptists. Collegiate friends and acquaintances were sometimes surprised to learn that I had been so raised. That's not uncommon in Wisconsin, where "Catholic or Lutheran?" is often the extent of people's understanding of theology. That there were at least three flavors of Lutheran was a subtlety many missed.
Wauwatosa's Underwood Church belonged to what we now know as the American Baptist Assembly, formerly the American Baptist Convention, and that association (even "synod" suggests way more organization than is the Baptist way) got its start when Roger Williams bridled at Puritan teachings, and the American Baptists, qua organization, emerged in 1845, over slavery. I think what my classmates had in mind when they heard "Baptist" was the Southern convention, which on the one hand included Billy Graham endorsing desegregation but on the other hand congregants and their clergy still have reservations about those alternative lifestyles and critical theory that have long been part of the Social Gospel as understood by Presbyterians and American Baptists alike.
Somehow, though, failing to cultivate the children of congregants made the Underwood Church so inclusive that nobody goes there any more. Thus, its late 1950s edifice is now home to immigrant Baptists from South Asia. History rhymes. The congregation was growing during the American High, enough so to build that church, and its existing Cream City brick church became home to Latvian Lutherans.
Among my mom's observations about the church failing children, she noted that the building itself was not kid-friendly, with only a perfunctory nursery and Sunday school classes in the basement "fellowship hall," which when not set up for potluck suppers, this being the Midwest, could be divided using heavy curtains into multiple meeting rooms for those classes. The ceiling wasn't high enough for basketball, although there was a stage at one end for variety shows.
That observation stuck with me and it might have had effect elsewhere. Years ago, the Lake Geneva Yacht Club had an opportunity to acquire property to protect its sailing complex. The first plans for an expanded clubhouse led me to observe something like "that floor plan might be labeled 'Geneva Lake Sailing School' but it is not at all friendly to kids." Thanks Mom. Nothing came of those plans, and I let my membership slide to pursue other interests, and only many years later did a new sailing center take shape on the south shore of Geneva Lake. The sailing school facilities are on the ground floor, with the restaurant and lounge upstairs, and there's a well-equipped tot lot sheltered from traffic with a good view of the lake. And the few times I've looked in since that sailing center opened, it's always been full of kiddos. Whether or not my long-ago observation stayed with any of the regulars, that sailing center is developing the next generation of Olympians. The extension to church infrastructure is left as a meditation.

No comments:
Post a Comment