Universities best serve their students through rigorous development of reasoning skills and respect for what we have learned. Rigor is likely to diminish incivility on campus, because students kept busy grappling with intellectual problems will have less time to fight with each other. Better that they be unhappy with a few demanding professors.They didn't listen, they did not know how.
Perhaps, notes Victor Hanson, they'll listen now.
For the first time in memory, a majority of Americans disapprove of current higher education. Only ten percent of Americans believe an Ivy League degree translates into becoming a better American worker.It might take some time to drain that swamp. Minding the Campus contributor Jared Gould takes stock.
In a nation of declining fertility, smaller numbers of youths choosing college, and a federal government $36 trillion in debt, universities have very little leverage.
They can return to the original mission of offering rigorous, meritocratic, and disinterested education, guarantee constitutional protections for all on campus, and slash their vast administrative bloat.
Or if not, they are free to continue as they are, ensuring only further mediocrity, public dislike—and eventual irrelevancy.
Critics may lament job losses, but the reality remains—Americans elected Trump to shrink our bloated bureaucracy, and he’s delivering. Even those who champion big government should at least acknowledge that departing bureaucrats are receiving generous severance packages—more than they’d likely receive in the private sector.The Department of Education has funded the ongoing reductions in test scores since its founding. And Inside Higher Ed contributor Joshua Kim is content for business as usual to continue.
Of course, eliminating [Education] entirely remains a taller order. As Minding the Campus contributor Richard Vedder notes, “Since [Education] was created by Congress, it would take formal Congressional action to eliminate it, and the administration lacks the votes.” Still, he argues, “the end of the ED would not be a mortal blow to education in America. Indeed, it might be a necessary precondition to ending the decline in learning at all levels, from pre-school to advanced adult professional education.”
And the swamp draining has stopped here, as higher education’s resistance to reform remains stubbornly entrenched.
According to Nate Silver’s 2024 book, On the Edge (which I read pre-election), you (probably) and I (definitely) are full citizens of the Village. And we Villagers are losing.Go ahead, marinate in the smug. Close the blinds and pretend the train is moving. And, this being Inside Higher Ed, continue with business as usual.
The Village consists of academics, scientists, nonpolitical federal government professionals, mainstream journalists and employees of moderate to liberal nonprofits, think tanks and professional organizations.
Ascendant is the River. Silver characterizes the River as an entrepreneurial, risk-taking, probabilistic thinking and expected value-maximizing class. The River runs strongly through the worlds of tech, finance, gambling and, lately, the federal government.
The last thing we citizens of the Village want to do at this current moment is read an entire book about how the River thinks. Most of my friends in the Village have never quite forgiven Silver for predicting (accurately, it turns out) a Trump victory.
We Villagers need to understand how the River thinks and learn to speak to Riverians by learning their language, customs and culture. On the Edge is a good place to start.Provide the rigorous development of reasoning skills, seasoned with respect for what we have learned, and stop the internal dismantling in the name of the latest French rot and you might be just fine.
I don’t think we will ever understand or find common ground with those who are working to dismantle the infrastructure of basic science and public health. Some canyons are too wide to cross.

2 comments:
The Village and the River...there are quite a few scientists involved in the high-risk venture world...indeed, many venture capitalists (who would be categorized as River, because finance) started their careers as scientists.
"River" and "Village" are false dichotomies, and there's something smug about how Mr Kim speaks of the like-mindedness of the so-called Village. It's possible that many of the leading minds of the River are more than a little bit wise to the ways, including the smug and the wine-snobbery, of the so-called Village. Maybe I read the book, maybe not.
Post a Comment