In Book Review No. 3 I argue that Professor Marshall is offering a more general indictment of the Technocratic Vision; the traffic engineers have run afoul of the same problem that trips up any gathering of Wise Experts, to wit: Complex Adaptive Systems Do Whatever They D**n Well Please. His chapters focus on traffic engineering, and yet, traffic engineering involves at least five levels of analysis, working from the foundational to the systemic.
First, the motor vehicle that Professor Marshall introduces at page 7 as a Faustian bargain ("God is going to give us a wondrous invention that will allow us to see new places, spend more time with family and friends, and do heretofore-unthinkable jobs. In exchange for this invention, God is going to select 1,000 people at random each year, including kids, and strike them dead.") is a Marshallian improvement, i.e. the gains in social welfare from that wondrous invention for most adopters exceed the losses; and the traffic engineers engage in an indisputably well-intentioned quest to free up the time whilst conserving lives. That they do so badly enough to call forth 88 theses is more an indictment of Process and Trust the Science(TM) than it is of providing space to park cars when they're idle and move them when their owners want to move: things that prices exist to allocate. Oh, wait.
Second, traffic itself is an emergent phenomenon, resisting the best efforts of the Men of System to manage it. A colleague published "Speeds in Traffic Equilibrium" years ago, identifying conditions under which motorists would sort themselves into a fast lane and a slow lane, and he got off quite the dig at the traffic engineers, noting "drivers are not molecules." So much for those analogies to water flow so popular back in the day. Go from a relatively easy isolated road to a network, and neglect the arbitrage opportunities that present themselves. We understand that phenomenon today as induced demand. The equilibrium driver will be indifferent as among the choices of routes from origin to destination. And the people who lay out expressways slowly catch on. When the first urban expressways opened, the boffins expected that people would use them to speed up their trip to work, and arranged the ramps accordingly. It didn't take motorists long to figure out that hopping on at one interchange and hopping off at the next was an easy way to avoid several traffic lights on the existing paralleling road. These days, when there's porkulus money to widen the expressway, that often involves providing a dedicated lane solely for that traffic (see the Indianapolis beltway for the concept in action) and people wanting to go further have to play ducks and drakes with traffic already expressing.
Third, and Professor Marshall devotes many chapters to this phenomenon, the Men of System are too much in thrall to their notions of "best practice" to, oh, look for the evidence that leads them to revise their priors. So it was with parking minima. So it is with zoning, although that's for another day. So it is also with what the Men of System call "Level of Service," but, in common with parking minima and zoning, a lot of the nostrums of "best practice" are unsupported by evidence, if they're not simply made up.
Marshall notes that many design standards and operational guides applied by traffic engineers were founded on whatever data they had at the time. Here, we are talking about the 1920s to the 1950s. In most cases, there have been no updates. “Good enough for now” turned into “It must be done this way.” Some “standards” were the products of lobbying and propaganda from the auto industry — a way to not only make the environment favorable for cars but also make cars necessary for everyday life. The entire suburban design philosophy used in this country since World War II has been intended to sell cars.He spares the economists the scorn that they deserve for helping quantify the value of those improved levels of service. I remember that sort of work: stratify by trip purpose, value the time savings on a journey to work at the commuter's hourly wage rate; value the time savings for shopping or recreation or picking up the kids at school at some fraction of that wage rate, and aggregate them up and count them as benefits. That people might combine trips (pick up bread on the way home from work, pick up the kids and go to Big Boy and then a movie) was beyond the computing capability of the models of the era: and maybe people would treat a road improvement like a brushless shaving cream and sleep in.
Fourth, we still have no idea whether an automobile-dominant infrastructure favors the development of urban centers (the Futurama vision) or the development of the exurbs (the Carousel of Progress vision.) Accordingly, we have no idea what the proper blend of roads for connecting places, arterial streets for commerce, and residential streets for living is. The same phenomenon that we understand as induced demand when your tax dollars expand a road presents itself as motorists looking for alternatives to what the county engineer designates as a main road once it becomes congested. And thus we see people using parallel residential streets to avoid that congestion, and people on those streets creating impromptu culs-de-sac, or favoring the suburban development pattern, or perhaps something like the Radburn plan, making the residential streets harder to navigate. Meanwhile the stroads are ever more dangerous to people in cars, let alone attempting to navigate them or cross them on a bike, on foot, with a mobility scooter. We're not yet to the stage of guillotining sport-ute drivers for running kids down, and yet the political economy of pedestrian deaths might inspire a Mme. DeFarge. "Milwaukee data reveals how past bad planning decisions have translated into disturbing traffic safety outcomes today — as well as big disparities in who's doing the killing and who's doing the dying."
Fifth, cities scaled to horse-drawn transportation and sailing ships have emerged over millennia. The railroads, featuring the fixed guideways of rivers and canals but with greater speed, did not disrupt patterns of long standing the way the bicycle and later the motor vehicle, with their active lobbying for better roads did. Yes, the cyclists and the motorists appear to be at odds these days, but it was the League of American Wheelmen who began the rent-seeking under the rubric of better roads (paid for by somebody else) that continues today. But only with a relatively powerful motor vehicle, and only in the flatlands of the United States at first, could conditions approximating the featureless plain of location models be exploited.
This review has already taken on the proportions of a Chicago-area traffic jam on a day the Cubs are in town. Let me wind it up first by recommending John December's book notes on Killed by a Traffic Engineer, reinforcing my five points and adding a few others. Those notes conclude with a recommended reading list. Second, check out Streetsblog California's Laura McCamy interviewing Mr Marshall. Be careful to finish your coffee before you go there.
(Cross-posted to 50 Book Challenge.)

No comments:
Post a Comment