Funnily, the author frames her thesis as an attempt to rebut a claim that has little basis in fact.
The setting was certainly an interesting choice on the part of the “Euphoria” star, who spent the better part of last year running from the controversy over her ad for American Eagle Outfitters—also a sponsor of this year’s Stagecoach—in which, following a brief explainer on genetic determinism, a voice-over boasted of the blond, blue-eyed actress’s “great jeans.” The inspiration had seemingly been “Genes,” a near-identical ad that Brooke Shields did for Calvin Klein in the nineteen-eighties, but, in 2025, jokes about Sweeney’s supposed physical supremacy appeared to be giving free press to a right-wing talking point. By then, conservatives had concocted a theory that the fifties-pinup physique of Sweeney, a registered Republican, was an affront to progressive sensibilities; a year earlier, the National Post, a right-leaning news site, had raised the question “Are Sydney Sweeney’s breasts double-D harbingers of the death of woke?” While we were pretending not to be looking, breasts had somehow become Republican-coded.Read on, and the basis for her confusion is clear. "When I was growing up, in the early two-thousands, 'conservative' meant conservative. The right was the party of George W. Bush, abstinence-only sex education, and Christian evangelical teens who recited chastity pledges and wore promise rings under the banner of 'True Love Waits.'"
None of which rules out developing a fifties-pinup physique or enjoying motor sports. Soon enough, dear reader, Rush Limbaugh's Undeniable Truth of Life No. 24 presents itself.
Outside, I’d passed a man holding a sign that read “Hot Girls Eat Arby’s.” Last summer, the sandwich chain, which is owned by Roark Capital Group—named for the protagonist of Ayn Rand’s “The Fountainhead”—hired Sophie Cunningham, a W.N.B.A. player for the Indiana Fever, as a brand ambassador. ... To announce the partnership, Cunningham posted a picture of herself slyly smiling in an Arby’s tee with the words “look who has the meats now.” How did this happen? How did the right get the meats?Mark Judge suggests we've seen the conservative politics of looking good before, and he suggests somebody who one might think has more in common with the Cosmopolitan that Miss Wilson misses.
“There’s been a mega-shift,” Raquel Debono, the founder of Make America Hot Again, which organizes mixers for young conservatives in New York City, told me. “It’s like the Mar-a-Lago face. Look at Fox News. Everyone’s got Botox, filler, and their tits out. It’s the bimbofication of MAGA.” The first election of Donald Trump, weeks after a 2005 “Access Hollywood” tape of him talking about grabbing women “by the pussy” was released, helped inspire the rise of “Barstool conservatism,” a kind of libertine libertarianism named for the comedy website Barstool Sports, whose founder, Dave Portnoy, once blogged that a certain female ESPN journalist’s “#1 requirement” was to “make men hard.” (Portnoy recently authored the memoir “Cancel Me If You Can.”) The “anti-woke” beer brand Ultra Right put out a “MAGA Babes” calendar that included women in red-white-and-blue bathing suits and Dana Loesch, the former Breitbart editor, hoisting two assault rifles into the air.
The new conservative sex champions bring to mind one of the last ones: Hugh Hefner. The founder of Playboy was pretty conservative. Hefner grew up in Chicago, was interested in magazines and cartooning from an early age, and struck gold in the 1950s when he purchased the rights to publish naked pictures of Marilyn Monroe. Yet from the start Playboy, whose first issue appeared in December 1953, was much more than a girlie magazine. Hefner had a great eye for talent of the non-nude variety, whether it was cartoonists and graphic artists or writers.Make of it what you will that "I read Playboy for the articles" has long been a gag line, while second wave feminists were too tolerant of the "militant man-haters" at the same time that they were seeking that same sort of "period of exploration" to establish one's career or what have you. It's all too much for Marina Hyde in The Guardian, who notes, "Sydney's gonna Sweeney." "I love it that she’s out there in the culture, pissing off reflexively judgmental people who ignore so many bigger issues but have really strong views on sexy ad campaigns." There's probably a serious overlap between "reflexively judgmental people" and judgmental people who fret about many bigger issues: continuing, by so doing, to provide play value for Cold Spring Shops posts.
In 1955 Esquire rejected “The Crooked Man,” a story by science fiction writer Charles Beaumont. It told the story of a man who lived in a homosexual society and was persecuted for being straight. Hefner published it. Hefner was a jazz fan, and the early Playboy ridiculed rock ‘n’ roll as “noise.” It also made fun of beatniks and hippies. Then there was Playboy’s ridicule of feminism. Here’s Playboy’s call-out accompanying a 1970 article about the feminist movement: “Militant man-haters do their level worst to distort the distinctions between male and female and they discredit the legitimate grievances of American women.” Such a piece today might appear in conservative media.
In Elizabeth Fraterrigo’s book Making of the Good Life in Modern America, the author explores Playboy’s place in American culture. The Playboy philosophy was never about making easy money through laziness and hedonism, and even nihilism, which is what so much modern porn is about. Hefner championed hard work and capitalism—“work hard and play hard” was a favorite phrase. He loved the booming 1920s and often harkened to them as an ideal time of great jazz and economic expansion, yet embraced modern technology and modernist art, architecture and graphic design.
Hefner also felt that an employed young bachelor was good for the American economy because of his disposable income. Playboy didn’t advocate the destruction of marriage, but rather letting a man have a period of exploration between college and marriage. Hefner married his first wife Mildred right out of college; the marriage didn’t last. Too many of the new young trad conservatives are preaching about marrying your first love and having kids almost right out of college. That’s an ideal model. It’s just not always the best one.


No comments:
Post a Comment